Why You Should Think Twice About Asking AI For Relationship Advice

TLDR: While it might feel helpful to ask AI for relationship advice, there are real risks. The goal of AI is to get you to use it more, not to give you honest feedback that will help you grow. A recent study found that AI agrees with you far more than a real human would, validated harmful and toxic behavior, and left users feeling convinced they were right, less willing to apologize or take responsibility, and less interested in resolving conflict with the other party. This can cause real harm in relationships and hurt your relationship skills.

2 people looking at a laptop and a cell phone. Using ChatGPT as a proxy for couples counselling can leave all parties dissatisfied. 90015 | 90266 | 90401

Many people use AI for relationship advice. And it makes sense - it can synthesize more information more quickly than you ever could, it’s free, and it’s accessible. But is it a good idea?

A fascinating study was recently published on the use of AI for relationship advice. A PhD student at Stanford named Myra Cheng noticed how many of her peers were asking AI for advice on navigating difficult relationship situations like conflict and breakups and decided to study this topic. 

The results were compelling enough and her study was rigorous and well conducted enough to get published in Science, one of the most prestigious and difficult to get published in journals out there. So what did she find, and why am I, as a therapist, talking about a study?

What kind of relationship advice does AI give?

Couple, backs to camera looking out the window symbolizing the struggles in communication when we rely on AI. Relationship therapy in LA can help. 90266 | 90274 | 90027

The study (which tested 11 AI models, including ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, etc.) found that AI agreed with users 49% more often than a human would, meaning in half the situations where a human would have pushed back or disagreed (even kindly), AI just… agreed. 

The researchers wanted to see how far this would go, so they fed AI models prompts that included descriptions of harmful behavior. Things like lying, manipulation, even illegal acts. Every single AI model validated this behavior almost half the time (47%). What this means is that even if you are engaging in harmful behavior, and telling AI about it as you ask for advice, it will cosign that behavior almost half the time. 

Lastly, they had participants tell the AI models about a real-life conflict from their own life with either the regular AI models (agreeable and validating of harmful behavior) or a more honest one. They found that the people using the agreeable AI models came away from the interactions more convinced they were right, less willing to apologize or repair the conflict, less likely to take accountability or responsibility for their part of the conflict, and MORE likely to ask AI for advice the next time they had a conflict.

Consider this direct quote from the article:

"The AI is not just telling you what you want to hear. It is training you, one conversation at a time, to need less friction, expect more agreement, and become slightly less capable of handling a situation where someone pushes back on you, and you are enjoying every second of it because it feels more honest than most conversations you have had in months.”

What are the risks of using AI for relationship advice?

Given the above findings, as well as what I have observed with clients, the risks of using AI for relationship advice include becoming dependent on it, losing your skills for navigating conflict, and harming your relationships. 

It could lead you to act in ways that are inconsistent with your values and hurt the people you care about. You could lose relationships, as defensive people who are convinced they are right and refuse to take accountability do. 

And if you become dependent on it and lose your tough conversation skills, what happens when you inevitably have a conflict and can’t access AI for advice?

Should I use AI for relationship advice? 

White modern sofa and brown furniture. Relying on AI for relationship advice can weaken our good communication skills which are fostered in psychotherapy in California. 90277 | 90094 | 90274

As a therapist who specializes in relationships and harm caused in relationships, I would recommend you avoid using AI for relationship advice. Setting aside the valid ethical, privacy, and environmental concerns people have about AI, the risks above are too great for me to feel comfortable encouraging use of it. Should therapy be more accessible for more people? Yes. Is it a problem if you use it every once in a while when a person is inaccessible? Maybe, maybe not. But certainly regular use of AI for relationship advice risks shifting you toward behaviors that will be harmful to your relationships and reduce your skills and confidence in navigating difficult conversations. 

Plus, don’t you actually want honest feedback about these types of situations (delivered kindly, of course)?

What’s more, the behaviors that the study found AI advice pushed people toward (being convinced they were right, less likely to apologize or take accountability, defensiveness when someone pushes back, and uninterested in repairing harm caused in relationships) are the very behaviors that harmed many of my therapy clients and many people who are struggling in relationships in the first place. Think about that for a second… most of us have been hurt by someone like this. Is this really who we want to become?

Start Therapy for Relationship Challenges in Los Angeles:

Look, relationships are HARD. Most of us didn’t have families that modeled perfect relationship communication, especially if dysfunctional family dynamics were present. Conflict is also inevitable in relationships. But there are skills you can learn to help you move through conflict in a way that is healthy, respectful to the other person AND yourself, and helps you get your needs met. A therapist specializing in relationships and women’s experiences can help. Start by following these steps:

  • Reach out for a consultation at Well Woman Psychology. 

  • Meet with a therapist specializing in women’s issues, relationships, and trauma.

  • Learn to communicate more effectively, with integrity, and in a way that honors your feelings and needs.

About the Author:

Dr. Linda Baggett is the founder of Well Woman Psychology, a virtual trauma-informed (EMDRIA™ certified) and weight-inclusive (Body Trust® Certified) therapy practice specializing in women in California, Colorado, Illinois, New York, and Washington. Dr. Baggett, a licensed psychologist, helps women navigate relationship challenges, trauma and anxiety so that they can thrive in relationships and life. She also assists women and gender diverse folks with body image, perinatal and postpartum issues, pregnancy loss and miscarriage, infertility and perimenopause and menopause.

Disclaimer: This blog is for educational and informational purposes only, is not a substitute for individual medical or mental health advice, and does not constitute a client-therapist relationship.

Next
Next

How Open Enrollment Can Help You Pay For Therapy